Will The Baxters be a blessing for Prime Video? Some folks are praying on it. Based on the Redemption literary series from No. 1 New York Times bestselling author Karen Kingsbury, The Baxters follows Elizabeth (Roma Downey of Touched by an Angel) and John Baxter (Ted McGinley of Happy Days, The Love Boat, Married… With Children), along with their five adult children. Season one revolves around daughter Kari (Ali Cobrin), who uncovers the shocking truth that her professor husband, Tim (Brandon Hirsch) has been having an affair with one of his college students. As her relationship is tested, Kari is forced to lean into her faith and family and discover if love is a choice and if her marriage can be saved.